Klawchat 11/4/16
Pretend-to-be chats don't seem to know they limitation. Klawchat.
Brad
So I get that Maybin was a lousy CF defensively, but he was still the only viable CF option in the Tigers organization. Al Avila saying there will be a competition between Tyler Collins, Anthony Gose and Jacoby Jones is all fluff, right? I can't see the Maybin trade being made unless Avila is confident he can get an MLB ready CF in a trade for JD Martinez or Ian Kinsler. Thoughts?
I don't think any of those three guys is a CF answer. Jones can't hit and I don't think he can play center. Collins can't play CF. Gose can't hit. I don't mind the Maybin trade because that's now two years of atrocious numbers for him in center, but the replacement isn't here.
Klaw
John Liotta
I know you have had a busy year this year, what with writing a book, etc., but have you been able to keep your reading pace from last year when you read 100 books?
I finished my 78th book in the car (audio, folks, settle down) today driving down from CT. I guess I'll end up with 90-odd? I'm working my way through the Pulitzer winners, which will slow me down because some of the remainders are very long.
Klaw
Marshall MN
Klaw have you already begun work on your Top 100 prospect list or do you give yourself a little bit of an "off season" once the series is done?
I can't get to that till I'm through free agent rankings.
Klaw
Jesse
Adam Rubin noted yesterday that the Mets are very high on 1B Peter Alonso. I was wondering if you could give some info on him and your general thoughts. I was surprised to hear this as most fans have heard of Dom Smith as the 1b of the future.
Alonso's a nice prospect, outside chance to be a regular, not as good as Smith - they're the same age, in fact, and Smith already has a solid season in AA behind him.
Klaw
Jeremy
Are we at the point where the White Sox just need to bite the bullet and do a complete rebuild?
I think that would be the right direction, given the farm system's thinness (although it's improved a lot in the last year-plus). It's hard to see them buying enough help to contend even with Sale and Quintana leading the rotation.
Klaw
Tom
Wednesday night was not just #fyeahbaseball, it was #fyeahsports.
I would agree with that. I love how many people are still talking about Game 7. When was the last time we had that? 2001?
Klaw
JT
What is the biggest move your foresee David Stearns making this winter ?
Unless he trades Ryan Braun I doubt there's a big move coming there.
Klaw
#FlyTheW
Hoping to pick your scouting brain and compare it to what I see with my untrained eye. Addison Russel seems to take a lot of fastballs for strikes early in the count and then often chases off-speed outside the zone later in the count. Do you think he would benefit for jumping in the first fastball he sees, or do you think he is taking the correct approach?
I don't know that that's necessarily true about his approach.
Klaw
Rich O
Do the Yankees make a move for an impact bat (i.e. Cespedes, Encarnacion etc) this offseason?
Is that what they really need? They have corner bats who need to play. If they go external it should be for pitching, not 1b/dh/lf types.
Klaw
Chuck
"In a world full of greed, we'll never want more..." is not entirely true. Do you see any of the Cubs prospects making a difference in Chicago next year? Johnson, maybe? And how long before Jimenez arrives?
Jimenez is at least two years off, I think - late 2018 would be the soonest I'd expect to see him. Clifton is probably 2018. Cease further off. Happ could appear in 2017, though I'm not sure where he would fit. Do you mean Pierce Johnson? He just had an awful year in AAA at 25, and I never liked his arm action, so I don't see any impact from him.
Klaw
Max
I've been pretty set on voting for Stein for quite some time, but with Killary apologists it's almost driving me to vote for the lesser of two evils from the big corporate party: Donald Trump. Your endless smear campaigns agaibst 3rd party candidates and white washing of every disgusting thing Clinton has done (you aren't the only one guilty of this to be fair) probably hasn't just alienated me I'd bet. I hope you and those following the same path as you know you're just driving people to vote this way.
I'm going to go on a limb and say that someone who refers to Clinton as "Killary" is perhaps not the most rational-minded voter in the electorate.
Klaw
MJ
Other than the managers and Theo, how many future HOF's in game 7? Lester? I assume it's too soon for Rizzo, Bryant and Lindor even though they are the right path.
Francona yes, Maddon probably has a ways to go but the ring helps. Lester no. Those three you named are all kids who are off to the right starts but way too far off to call any future HoFers. Zobrist has 40 career fWAR - is he the leader on both rosters?
Klaw
Dave
Know you don't watch a ton of TV, but any current favorites? I'm currently addicted to Shameless for what it's worth.
Not really. We watch Brooklyn 99, a little behind on the Good Place, and that's about it. Got some stuff we want to binge on now that the season's over but we'll see if that happens.
Klaw
jimbonova
Criticism of ownership and sports "journalism:" It seems to be me that certain issues are off-limits to sports media. For instance, mistakes by ownership. I am a Red Sox fan and while this ownership group has brought three World Series trophies to the team, it is apparent that they are responsible for many missteps (e.g., departure of Epstein, Francona, Lester, Hazen, Sawdaye), yet there is little reported about these kinds fo mistakes in the press. I live in the Washington DC area and find this true of local ownership in all four of the major sports. Any thoughts?
Media need for access colors all kind of commentary. But I think some ownership missteps have come under fire, like the fiasco in Arizona the last two years. A reader also pointed out how Moorad ran Hoyer and McLeod out of San Diego (and Jaron Madison too), and now those guys helped the Cubs win a ring. Angelos has gotten his share of criticism for protecting certain employees in baseball ops during GM changes. So there could be more criticism, but certainly some come out.
Klaw
Eric
Call me a cynic, but am I the only one that finds it odd when people comment "We forgive you Bart man!" Shouldn't it be Bartman doing the forgiving? He had to fear for his life for what is, at the end of the day, some silly sports thing.
The fan and media reaction to and ongoing fascination with Bartman is disgusting.
Klaw
Tye
What's your favorite ESPN show to watch? (Not including Baseball Tonight or Sportscenter)
Outside the Lines is the best show on ESPN.
Klaw
Eddy
Were Xander's 21 HR a natural progression for him? Is that his peak? 2016 seemed like a great eyar for him, but can he get better?
I think he has 30+ potential.
Klaw
Rich O
Do you see the Yankees and Tigers as a potential match for a JD Martinez trade?
Again, I see no reason for the Yankees to acquire a corner bat, especially not a poor defender like JDM.
Klaw
Dave
Are you or have you ever been a member of the band Arcade Fire?
Let me check and get back to you.
Klaw
Scott of Lincolnshire
Every World Series winner has clubs that try to copy something that they did unique to win. What do teams try to take from the Cubs championship?
Get high draft picks, trade aggressively, and spend a few hundred million on long-term deals?
Klaw
Mike
Now that the WS is over, will ESPN be publishing your top prospects for the 2017 draft soon ? Is Alex Toral a top 10 pick (despite the fact he's a HS 1B only) ?
Toral is not a top 10 pick or close to it. Last I heard, they're going to run my free agent and trade-market preview content first, and then the draft rankings. I'm sorry for the delays but the schedule is not my decision.
Klaw
Anthony
Last year in a chat you said regarding a potential move by the Rangers of Josh Morgan to catcher: "I love the idea. Could be a Russell Martin type back there." Two follow-ups to that. One: why would Morgan be more valuable as a C than a middle infielder -- just that you don't think he can handle 2b or SS or something else? 2: This off-season there is renewed talk of trying Morgan at C, do you remain optimistic about Morgan, especially if he takes to such a change? Thanks!
Morgan isn't a SS, and replacement level at C is much lower than it is at 2b. I'd be very optimistic if they fully commit to the conversion now.
Klaw
Pat D
If the Cubs had lost, ____% of the blame would have gone to Maddon, and ____% would have been justified?
100% and maybe 40%. I thought he made two clear mistakes: bringing in Chapman with a man on and having Baez bunt with two strikes. Those were indefensible. I thought pulling Hendricks for Lester was overreactive, but not absolutely a mistake - Hendricks isn't really a 2 ERA guy and he'd already gone through the order twice (I think). The ump blowing the third strike call was the bigger mistake in that inning, and so was Ross making a late, errant throw to first on a ball he should have held.
Klaw
Brian
What needs do the Indians have to address in the offseason to become contenders again?
Get the rotation fully healthy, get Brantley healthy, determine who the CF will be going forward (can Naquin, who runs well but was awful in CF this year, become at least average?), maybe patch a little around the edges of the roster. I don't think they're really lacking anywhere.
Klaw
Adam
Obviously the Braves are rebuilding the farm with arms, so what do you think of yesterday's hires of Wallace and Chiti?
Mixed feelings. Britton credits Wallace with helping make him a new Mariano Rivera, but the moves of Gausman around the rubber, the overuse of Bundy, monkeying with other deliveries ... do I want that same guy around all those young Atlanta pitchers?
Klaw
DC Deac
You were always pretty negative on Severino as an ace for the Yanks mostly due to mechanics. Did we see that this year or was this meltdown something different?
I didn't think he could hold up or have sufficient command to be a starter. That's what happened this year. I'd leave him in the pen now, where I think he could be pretty electric.
Klaw
Hinkie
Cameron Rupp, Andrew Knapp, Jorge Alfaro ... what do the Phillies do with these three guys next season?
Marry, f... oh wait, wrong game. I'd play Rupp regularly and Knapp as the backup, Alfaro to AAA with some clear thresholds for him (that he understands) before he's promoted. He has to work the count more, and he has to receive better.
Klaw
Jesse
Baring any major acquisitions or subtractions and assuming Cespedes doesn't return, how should mets best align their OF? I think Lagares should be playing everyday but not sure how they will make that work
Conforto plays LF every day. Everything else comes after that.
Klaw
Nelson
People sure like to forget that Bill Murray abused his wife for years
His public image doesn't line up well with stories people close to him tell about his temperament or his behavior. (Murray's wife of about ten years accused him of abusing her and threatening to kill her; she withdrew the claims after their divorce settlement.)
Klaw
Chris
Would you give Neil Walker a QO? I think I'd take it if I was him. Not sure of his market outside of NY with that balky back.
Yes, and probably yes.
Klaw
Nils
Hi Keith, does Blake Swihart still have a future as a C? Is he a change of scenery candidate?
Yes, and probably yes.
Klaw
DH
T/F: the best fit for Fowler this offseason is the Cardinals, and they will give him 4/64
That's a good call, actually. I don't spend much time thinking about best fits, though.
Klaw
Jeff Chisholm
I remember you recommending "The Fresh Beat Band" a while ago for family viewing. I just watched it with my daughter and can't understand what you see in it. Can you explain? Maybe it was just a bad episode I saw
I assume this is a joke, because I complained for years that it was one of the worst kids' shows I'd ever seen. I had successfully forgotten about it until just now, so thanks for nothing.
Klaw
ryan
everyone always says, 'oh they'll be back' especially for whoever loses the WS - but if one of these two teams doesn't make it back, which one is it more likely to be?
Cleveland's payroll limitations are a serious issue. They will never have the margin for error the Cubs had. It's amazing that they made it to Game 7 despite losing two of their three best starters.
Klaw
Ryan
I'm happy the cubs won at least so we can retire the idea that curses and voo doo magic are reasons that transcend team performance
Yes, more of this superstition-killing, please.
Klaw
Nate
Keith, if you were Rick Hahn, would you sell or attempt to buy/build around that core?
Per above, I don't think he could build a strong contender around the current core.
Klaw
Matthew
If you were in Cleveland's front office, would you consider shopping Andrew Miller this offseason?
I'd take offers, with no clear incentive to trade him unless overwhelmed.
Klaw
CarlC
I read that excellent Frey article you linked too. This may be a 30 year old argument, but Im guessing male media members would never be allowed in a WNBA locker room, right?
I'm almost certain that they are.
Klaw
JMD
What should the mets do at C? d'arnaud seems like he isn't durable enough and hasn't produced when he's played. Plawecki hasn't made much impression. Should they go external? Weiters?
I'd play Plawecki and tell the manager to stop fucking running down his players to the media (which he did to Plawecki in May).
Klaw
Nick
If there ends up being an International Draft, do you think the the current J2 rules will apply in terms of eligibility or will rules more akin to the Rule 4 Drafr apply? If the latter, this poses an interesting predicatment for 15/16 year old int'l players.
I can't imagine MLB forcing those kids to wait till age 17/18. It's not like Dominican kids are finishing high school. I'd really object to any rule of the sort that clearly hurts the kids.
Klaw
Ryan
Keith, What should I say to people who say pitchers should not be able to win the MVP because "they have their own award"?
I say read the MVP rules, genius.
Klaw
Fear
Are you afraid of what will happen post-election, regardless of who wins? I have this great fear (I think justified) that if Trump loses, some of his supporters will go on violent rampages, believing that the election was rigged and they need to get justice their own way.
Yes, I am fearful both ways. I'm generally fearful that Trump's bogus claims of rigging and voter fraud have eroded some faith in our democracy, period, at least in the portions of the country where he has the most support. And I'm disgusted with the media for covering his claims without anywhere near sufficient skepticism.
Klaw
Andy
It's a shame that David Ross's clubhouse leadership disappeared in 2014 in Boston. Luckily it reappeared in the last couple years when he was surrounded by some really good teammates. Perhaps good clubhouse leadership is really about being a solid backup catcher. Or in the case of last year, his leadership lead to the Cubs trading away Wellington Castillo for basically nothing.
Grey hair in the beard helps too. In which case my clubhouse leadership skills have advanced substantially in the last year.
Klaw
Ron
Any thoughts on your alma mater's decision to cancel the soccer season?
I support Harvard's decision 100% and I'm proud of them for doing the right thing. Would that Baylor had done the same with football.
Klaw
Albert
Keith, have you seen the Real Sports piece about balls and strikes being called by a computer and relayed to the umpire? I'd like to see that happen. Your thoughts? Also, if you're thinking about binge watching a TV show Silicon Valley is genius. I think you'd enjoy it.
That piece used raw data that had not been checked and cleaned for reliability (e.g., throwing out bad readings by the system, which unfortunately do occur), and so the results weren't valid. I agree on moving towards computerized ball/strike calls, as most of you know, but that study didn't present the right conclusions.
Klaw
Aaron
You were fairly critical of the Reds' haul in the Cueto trade. Does their trade of Lamb for just cash give further credence to your initial assessment?
Well, he was probably the third of three pieces, so I don't know that I'd say this changes much. Reed should be a lot better than he showed in 2016 - that has been the big shock to me.
Klaw
Scrapper
What do you expect next season from Alex Bregman?
Makes the All-Star team.
Klaw
Drew
Knowing that ridiculing someone's stance only entrenches them further into their position, regardless how illogical it might be, how do you balance the choice of trying to change minds as opposed to saying "Eff it, you deserved be be ostracized"
I know this is probably about the election, but i compare it to vaccine deniers. If you don't want to vaccinate your kids, well, fine, but they can't come to public schools, and we're not interacting with you in any way. We have to make the cost of denial high enough that more people choose to comply with public health rules.
Klaw
John
There is some sort of irony to all the criticism of how crooked Hillary is. Due to numerous, often times partisan rather than legitimate, investigations, and the hacks you are as close to absolute transparency as you can get. And what did we find, she does things any typical politician does, some of which are morally questionable, but don’t cross the line to illegality. Whereas Trump is the least transparent candidate ever, is under investigation for criminal fraud, and reporters have raised numerous questions on what appear to be numerous explicit violations of charity law by his personal charity, which has already lead to a cease and desist soliciting donations order from the NY dept. that monitors charities, not to mention the stiffing of numerous vendors for over 30 years. Yet she is the crooked one.
I agree with this completely. And I've never defended Hillary as particularly moral, ethical, or 'clean' compared to other politicians. But she's not a virulent racist, or misogynist, not dog-whistling white supremacists, not talking about using nuclear weapons, and not proposing tax-code changes to benefit the highest income brackets.
Klaw
Doug
What's a good game that a 5 year old, a 7 year old, and a 9 year old can all play?
Ticket to Ride. You'll have to help the 5-year-old a little bit.
Klaw