Once again it's another chat bandit. Klawchat.

3b16c9d4c4c856ce7fff405e3b6c43ab?d=identicon

BK

If you were Carlos Correa, how much would it cost for you to sign a lifetime deal with the Astros? Essentially, what sum of money could buy you out of ever signing another contract?

A lifetime deal would need a term - ten years? Fifteen? I'd be looking for something in the $40 million a year range for him, Harper, etc. Salaries are clearly headed that way anyway, and if owners have the cash, then the players should get it since they're the product.

28/12/2015 18:03
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3b55c1213d3dd7b8c3c814c18253289a?d=identicon

Dana

Do you believe that Brian Cashman is one of the best GM's in the game? Joel Sherman noted that the Yanks have been competitive for 23 straight seasons. That's impressive regardless of market size.

"Competitive" is a bit of an arbitrary standard, no? I think Cashman has done some things very well, some less so, and he operates under some constraints that aren't immediately visible to those of us on the outside.

28/12/2015 18:04
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Ea2bfa79cd221f1e88a9bf39ea155cd8?d=identicon

Charlie

I'm a Nats fan and while I totally get why the Nats don't want to go into the season with a possibly-not-ready Trea Turner and an unpredictable Espinosa, I don't love the Murphy deal. However, if they used him to spell Werth, Rendon, and Zim once a week, I might like it more? What are your thoughts on Daniel Murphy as a part-time 2B, part-time supersub? Could it work? Or, now that he's been signed, are they better just sticking him at second?

If they use Murphy to spell Rendon for any reason other than injury, they should send the entire coaching staff down the Potomac in a leaky rowboat. Also, the contract was way beyond what Murphy is likely to be worth even factoring in further salary inflation.

28/12/2015 18:05
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E8315caa4eb8c2a2625d4e97dbba100a?d=identicon

bruce

Best Sabbath album?

Has to be Paranoid, no? Title track, Iron Man, War Pigs.

28/12/2015 18:05
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

F95c49648e55e9f27749a8e8cdebefee?d=identicon

Alex in Austin

Dave Stewart won't be in Arizona in 3 years when Swanson is ready. Isn't this a problem of aligning incentives? How do you fix short and long term vision? Seems like the only constant is the owner, is the onus on him?

Swanson is likely to be ready by Opening Day 2017, if not sooner. It's not a question of misaligned incentives; it's a question of mishiring your general manager.

28/12/2015 18:05
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

43ed509ad8c3246f684edde268e8fbdc?d=identicon

KlawFan

Higher Upside: Benentendi or AJ Reed?

Benintendi. CF with speed as well as power. Reed is 1b only, has power and great approach, no speed and bat might be a tick slow for better velocity.

28/12/2015 18:06
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

532762fa5a5b7169aa4dd24717ba9df9?d=identicon

Pat

Aaron Judge's struggles at triple A: small sample or very concerning?

He has a specific approach issue - he hasn't learned to cover the outside corner while he's also covering the inner third - that explained the AAA struggles and even the AA strikeouts. I think he's still got some work to do in the minors.

28/12/2015 18:07
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E4d5185ea3d4db4d1067adc9aa5f8b16?d=identicon

Shaun

Any restaurant recommendations for Walt Disney World? Went to Raglan Road on your suggestion and loved it.

Jiko at Animal Kingdom Lodge is probably the best restaurant I've been to anywhere on the property. Via Napoli at Italy in Epcot is very good, but like most restaurants in the parks, very expensive for what you get.

28/12/2015 18:07
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

7efd721c8bfff2937c66235f2d0dbac1?d=identicon

Adam

Keith, do you think the trade for Jedd Gyorko signals the Cardinals frustration with Kolten Wongs progression, or do you see Gyorko as a backup at 2B/3B as well as a power bat off the bench? I would hate to see Wong not get another full season to see what he can be. What do you see happening in St Louis?

Gyorko is a good UT who can handle 2b or 3b and fake SS. They needed a RHB off the bench anyway and Wong has been a cipher vs lefties so far, so platooning them right now is a good idea.

28/12/2015 18:08
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

B46489c11cc0cf01e2f987c0237263f9?d=identicon

Craig

David Stearns has really focused on acquiring talent at the rookie/A ball level in trades. Has Stearns found a market inefficiency (teams don't properly value prospects who are several years away from the majors) or is this just a function of starting a rebuilding process that is likely to last several seasons?

I think the latter. Teams value those kids properly - they're very high risk and a long way away, so the present value of their likely production is really low. Stearns can afford to wait. He might be able to rent a car by himself when they reach the majors. (Sorry, Dave...)

28/12/2015 18:09
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

9fce00743851f57fa79b19de91687c67?d=identicon

Bill G.

Hi Keith. You have stated that OPS is too simplistic a metric, and it undervalues OBP (I agree). If you were to uplift OBP over SLG, what sort of uplift would you apply to make this a more realistic metric. Thanks.

I wouldn't. Keep them separate. Combining them only obscures valuable information.

28/12/2015 18:09
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

5257e05cde806e07b405ddcce85114d2?d=identicon

Bradley

Any thoughts on the Padres Rule 5 Draft additions. Sounds like they may give Perdomo a shot at the rotation. Do you think Blash makes enough contact for his power to show?

Never been a Blash fan. Perdomo should stick as a reliever. Two pitch guy, doubt he can start right now.

28/12/2015 18:10
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

6bee676d966337a34249d526fb67897f?d=identicon

Delvin Perez

Hi Mr.Law, do you think I have a chance to be a top 3 pick in next year draft?, I'm a huge Braves Fan.....

That's a stretch right now, but possible. You're just 17 and very toolsy.

28/12/2015 18:10
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

93c4a933d869a27243edaff79379ca32?d=identicon

Archie

Do you think the Murphy signing affects Trea Turner's Opening Day status?

I think it shouldn't but I bet it does.

28/12/2015 18:10
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D3d4c5deb455ac79dd5ff47c88bd65d9?d=identicon

PS

What do you think Rob Refsnyder's ceiling is? Is it Daniel Murphy?

Less. Can't play 2b at all and really doesn't even have Murphy's hit tool.

28/12/2015 18:10
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

52ea949b8fa68407d8739601cfcc3df6?d=identicon

Mikey

Thoughts on the whole Al-Jazeera doping debacle?

I don't see why we're doubting the story. People questioning Al-Jazeera's credibility as a news organization have been living under a rock for the last five years. No one covered the Arab Spring as well as they did - and they are hated by many dictators in the Arab world, which is as good a sign of integrity as you can have as a news organization.

28/12/2015 18:11
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

083d9a270e6e16b2fbb08d35067aae5f?d=identicon

Dave

Thoughts on Albert Almora's improved second half?

SSS until proven otherwise. Minor leaguers should improve in the second half if they don't move up, since their competition is getting younger due to promotions. As for Almora, I don't see any reason to think it's not just BABIP-related; he didn't hit for any power in the second half.

28/12/2015 18:13
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Cdb6de50014c1e696f4b8c0c3fb0f708?d=identicon

Roy

Of all the CF's the Red Sox have, who do you think actually ends up in the position in a couple of years. (Assuming no moves.)

Betts is the most likely to still be on the roster. Benintendi may actually be the CF, but Betts isn't going anywhere.

28/12/2015 18:13
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E58bdc5161a07b5ac6384db8de9173e7?d=identicon

Philly

Most industry analysts seem to be on board with the Phillies rebuilding efforts. I believe they have the correct course of action, but I am somewhat apprehensive that their returns on trades will yield more quantity than quality. Other than Crawford, do you really see anyone in their system with all star upside?

Quantity isn't a bad thing when the system is light on both. Randolph has star upside if he can find a position and they had a few arms in short-season ball with that kind of potential.

28/12/2015 18:14
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

8aae3a73a9a43ee6b04dfd986fe9d136?d=identicon

Andrew

Finally read Moneyball by Michael Lewis after years of reading you, baseballprospectus, and fangraphs. Thought it was nice of Lewis to mention you as JP's pet sabermetrician and mini-rain man. Anyway, I found your review of the movie but do you have anything on the book? Would love to hear your thoughts? How things have changed since it was written? Was shocked by how little defense was valued to the point where Beane would have traded Jason Varitek.

Book is a must-read, despite some factual issues. (The story with me never happened, and Lewis never corrected it even though I told him so after the hardcover edition. The quote about Voros from Depodesta actually came from me, and the story about a player seeing Mattingly at Legends Field is also untrue.) But for a general view of the industry at the time that avoids too much math and emphasizes the impact on specific players, it's outstanding. Lewis is a fantastic storyteller and I could read his prose all day long.

28/12/2015 18:16
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Ce2804ecaffb99c70aed2836c2983236?d=identicon

Anonymous

10 years from now, which current SS prospect is the better player? Dansby or Brendan Rodgers?

Rodgers, for me at least.

28/12/2015 18:16
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

6b5b50253f518631ddc0588558881f7d?d=identicon

greg p

How is the trade for Giles going to look two years down the road? A total heist for Phillies?

I think both sides end up very happy with it but we will say the Phillies did better in the end.

28/12/2015 18:16
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

F95c49648e55e9f27749a8e8cdebefee?d=identicon

Alex in Austin

In the next 30 years, do you see this antiquated arbitration system and underpaying younger players getting resolved? What if a new 4 team league is created that pays players under 27 their true value and attracted guys like Correa, Bryant, Fernandez, etc.?

Who funds that league? Not that I dislike the idea, but the barrier to entry for a rival league today is probably a dealbreaker for any of the four major sports.

28/12/2015 18:17
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

B0ec04c86d66c2bd0bc674d587368b04?d=identicon

Anonymous

Can the Braves realistically compete in 2017 with the new stadium opening? It seems like they are loading up on pitching prospects but will have no offense besides Freeman and Olivera

And Olivera may not even be that good. I don't think they can compete next year but they'll be sneaky good, and I bet they go spend some money next winter, or even on a late signing this winter if they see some value.

28/12/2015 18:17
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D12294be8c605ae1515d8091460b1aac?d=identicon

Anonymous

Re: Opt Outs from last time. There's also the PR positive from the team perspective. We signed this guy to this huge contract, look we're trying to win! Then if he opts out in a couple of years before he gets expensive, our fans (government) will hopefully have been stupid enough to build us a stadium to fill with less expensive ball players. #Profit

I laughed. You're not wrong about the PR benefit. No one realizes the opt-outs are there on signing day.

28/12/2015 18:18
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

A6978965678660635f2b8b4f587eabcd?d=identicon

Arin

What are reasonable number to expect from Hector Olivera? 4th OF, Average, Above Average, All-star?

thanks

I think extra guy. Questions on the hit tool and athleticism, and of course him bailing on Caguas (at least, not putting in the required level of effort) doesn't look good.

28/12/2015 18:18
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D7ed9d7159a4ee762f8b8fbd646efe9e?d=identicon

Bryan

Just curious about your thoughts on Sam Travis. Seems to be trending in the right direction.

I'm a fan. Can absolutely hit. Just not sure what the final power output is, and whether he's just a good regular at first or something more.

28/12/2015 18:18
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D3d4c5deb455ac79dd5ff47c88bd65d9?d=identicon

PS

I know some teams are spending more on coaching staffs in the minors these days, but their pay is still well short of MLB coaches. Couldn't you argue they are more important than MLB coaches based on the impact they have on developing players?

Best coaches end up promoted out of the area where they can do the most good.

28/12/2015 18:19
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

255a5cac7685572274d02f04c37be771?d=identicon

tw

How do you feel about your colleague's piece accusing the phillies of tanking? Indefensible, I assume, given the numerous contradictions of his prior writings? Also the absurd recommendations essentially demanding they give out bad contracts again...

Accusing? Is this even a question? They're doing what the Astros did and I don't see the problem with it. The system more or less forces bad teams to go that route. I only disagreed with Buster on the need for them to spend some money in the short term. F that. If the CBA incentivizes (I hate that word) tanking, then tank the shit out of it, my man.

28/12/2015 18:20
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

7c1f90bd9bdc70cc059640a7a6209389?d=identicon

Matt

Do you think college educated people truly think evolution is false and that creationism is true? Even if you take a class like biology or anatomy, it's clear evolution is true. I just don't understand how law makers can deny evolution. You had mentioned cognitive dissonance on Twitter, but I think there has to be a bigger reason.

I think, like many science and even social issues, it's about undermining the confidence some people might have in their religious beliefs. If evolution is true, does that mean Christianity is false? I don't happen to think that's the case, but if your religion tells you evolution is false, and the evidence says that it's true (it is, absolutely, 100%, no doubt about it true), then you may reject the evidence because it could force you to question your faith, or your belief in God or an afterlife. I think the fight against marriage equality came down to the same reason. Even climate change has a whiff of that - how could a just deity allow our planet to go to hell like that? (I'm reminded of the old Robin Williams quote from God: "I gave you a nice planet, and you fucked it up.")

28/12/2015 18:22
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

861565831545afb68057b15adeaa3045?d=identicon

Urban

Starlin Castro was not s good defensive SS, at least by the scouting side. Advanced metrics seemed to be kinder than the eye test. What's his projection as s defender at 2B?

I bet he's above-average to plus there.

28/12/2015 18:22
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E1271e594ea53336c212f2febc2ccdd6?d=identicon

Josh

Is kyler Murray eligible for the next draft?

Not as long as he's at a four-year school in the spring. Next eligibility would be in 2018.

28/12/2015 18:23
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D3d4c5deb455ac79dd5ff47c88bd65d9?d=identicon

PS

Who do you suspect the Yankees will target at 19th pick this year (obviously way too early)? Quantrill?

Zero idea. Teams don't do that this far in advance. You can't "target" anyone before the season has even started.

28/12/2015 18:23
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

A36e5df6089966dca4b38397aae00efd?d=identicon

Stephen

No question. Just a thanks. Every question I ask you on Twitter you seem to answer despite what has to be endless mentions. Just appreciate it.

You're quite welcome. Thank you for bearing with me as I tweet a lot and some of it probably isn't very good.

28/12/2015 18:24
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

7f15f1ad99c489dc0314952535e424d5?d=identicon

Jeff

Do you think Tyler Jay will become a successful starter?

I'd give him every chance to do so.

28/12/2015 18:24
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E1271e594ea53336c212f2febc2ccdd6?d=identicon

Josh

Who would be your guess to be the number 1 overall pick right now?

Dunno. Hansen, Groome, maybe Benson? I have no conviction on this topic at the moment.

28/12/2015 18:24
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

131b98dac8609f781484f08c22a8abaa?d=identicon

Ryan

What's your favorite way to prepare/cook a Pork Tenderloin?

Ruhlman's sear-roasting with lots of butter. Pork tenderloin has very little taste and is awful if cooked past medium-rare. It needs a rich sauce and a good crust on the outside.

28/12/2015 18:24
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

F2mqo68n normal

Scherzer's Blue Eye

Reason we're doubting could possibly be Charlie Sly has recanted his testimony? Maybe that hits at the credibility a bit...

Maybe a lawyer or two got to him. Testimony was awfully specific the first time around.

28/12/2015 18:25
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D0f7423e6e494bbabdbd1039696d474a?d=identicon

Dennis

Can Tomlinson be a super utility guy for the Giants, or is the bat just not good enough?

I'd say probably not, but I'm much more confident that he's not a regular than I am that he's not a 400 AB UT.

28/12/2015 18:25
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

131b98dac8609f781484f08c22a8abaa?d=identicon

Ryan

Why can't I make mayo taste as good as bottled? tips?

Use really good eggs and some fresh lemon juice. Try olive oil for the fat, or add another flavor like white miso or chipotle peppers.

28/12/2015 18:26
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3e06fa3927cbdf4e9d93ba4541acce86?d=identicon

Michael

What do pro scouts do during the winter?

Sit home, stare out the window, and wait for spring?

28/12/2015 18:26
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Be66cae8f1ed3eb6b0f36cb5f6a67940?d=identicon

Macon

Your thoughts on the ending of "A Farewell to Arms"??

No joke, I threw the book against the wall in high school when I got to the end. Silver Linings Playbook hadn't even been written yet.

28/12/2015 18:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

1b83d5da74032b6a750ef12210642eea?d=identicon

Mike

Al Jazeera is great...the only people questioning the report on that basis are morons. I think the issue is more that the documentary isn't all that great, and the allegations are based entirely on hearsay.

Fair. Although people had no problems believing hearsay allegations against Clemens.

28/12/2015 18:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

24d22e03afb23edb45c6c8cfa16a280e?d=identicon

JP

did you see the new Star Wars? thoughts?

Nope, probably won't see it for a while.

28/12/2015 18:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

1c0a11cc4ddc0dbd3fa4d77232a4e22e?d=identicon

Aaron

You were quite bullish on Amed Rosario's tools last winter. What, if anything, has change 10 months later?

Nothing. Tools are the same.

28/12/2015 18:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

C161dca1adb6836fdc8de3155ad46ba5?d=identicon

Elton

With Parks and Rec gone, what's the next best successor in that line of comedy? Have you watched Master of None?

That would be my pick. Watched the whole season. Last 5-6 episodes they really hit their stride, and some of the stuff on long-term relationships was expertly written. I was incredibly impressed.

28/12/2015 18:28
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

532762fa5a5b7169aa4dd24717ba9df9?d=identicon

Pat

How many SS prospects do you have ahead of Mateo?

Quite a few. He's a good prospect but getting a bit overhyped because of his parent org.

28/12/2015 18:28
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

20668f7d52bd0e55a31e2e2bd5f9195e?d=identicon

Anonymous

How likely is Moncada to stick at 2b?

I see no reason he won't.

28/12/2015 18:28
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

24dbc2b917472b089a5052b23f11f30f?d=identicon

Tyler

If you had to be a writer for any other sport, which would you choose?

Is food a sport?

28/12/2015 18:29
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

97c8e6d0d14f4e242c3c37af68cc376c?d=identicon

Dan

Hey Keith, my wife is having a brain tumor removed next month and I'm distracting myself by figuring out what to read during the hospital stay. I can't decide if I should go with something lighthearted/easy to read, something harder (since I'll have the time), something more bleak (since I'll be in that mood anyways), or something more educational (ie The Sixth Extinction). What do you recommend?

Good grief, that's not good news and I hope everything goes well for her. In situations like that, I stick to lighter fare that I can truly get lost in - authors I love, or the type of immersive book where I'll zone out a bit and feel completely "in" the pages. I don't read bleak stuff when I'm down or when I'm away from home for a long time.

28/12/2015 18:30
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw