If knowledge is the key, then I think it's time you learn. Klawchat.

Db320f93ead463e1a2faee198cd9a122?d=identicon

Nathan

How quickly do you expect Hunter Greene to move through the minors once drafted? As a SS/P will he need extra seasoning on the mound or could he follow a Julio Urias trajectory if everything clicks?

I don't think he's a fast mover, but I also don't think this is about being a two-way guy - he's athletic as hell with an 80 fastball and, if it is possible to throw an 'easy' 100, he does, but his secondary stuff isn't that advanced and he's a ways from average command. He's better than Riley Pint at the same stage, though.

16/02/2017 19:09
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3e06fa3927cbdf4e9d93ba4541acce86?d=identicon

Michael

Is it time to cut bait on Joey Gallo as an MLB regular? Seems to be a long shot to start in Texas out of spring training.

Joey Gallo is 23 years old. Talk of "cutting bait" on him as a regular is beyond premature. It's a trumpian overreaction.

16/02/2017 19:10
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3e06fa3927cbdf4e9d93ba4541acce86?d=identicon

Michael

Can Jose Berrios be a 2-3 starter or is his fastball too flat as some have asserted?

As *I* have asserted, you mean. I don't think he's ever going to be a 2.

16/02/2017 19:11
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E1271e594ea53336c212f2febc2ccdd6?d=identicon

Josh

No question. Just wanted to thank you for all the work you do & for voicing your beliefs in non-baseball related arenas.

You're welcome. I appreciate all the readers who've spoken up in support of me speaking up, so to speak.

16/02/2017 19:11
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

B80d6a6dde1a5a70cc22f907f97435d5?d=identicon

Papa K.

Do you think the Braves are making a mistake but not allowing Jace Peterson a chance to play full time at second base ?

No, I think he's a utility IF.

16/02/2017 19:11
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

F0a1a922df7ae6e105f09301b0ffee3c?d=identicon

guren

I gather from previous chats, etc. that wine is not your preferred adult beverage. Do you still have an open mind with regard to wine appreciation, or do you think that boat has left the harbor?

I've never enjoyed wine. If you put a decent wine in front of me, I'll drink it, but it's never my choice, and my knowledge of what's good is incredibly limited.

16/02/2017 19:12
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

2fc1c0beb992cd7096975cfebf9d5c3b?d=identicon

Bob

Hi Keith - won't be on during chat so hope you answer. Dave Stewart, paraphrasing that "his gut told him to not trade Dansby Swanson " Didn't his gut tell him to make that trade - I forget what his gut says. But he "was overruled by three people". I am guessing the three are Kendrick, LaRussa and Hall. And Kendrick makes sense, he is a meddler. My question, as GM - if you are told to make that trade - why not just quit if your "gut" says its wrong

Stewart said that, and Trump said he "inherited a mess." Here's a hint: I think they're both lying.

16/02/2017 19:13
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

65dab5799c982d5e0b2e2637523064c9?d=identicon

joshkvt

What's missing in the min wage debate is that raising it a reasonable amount also helps — not hurts — those making more. A skilled/educated worker making $16 now would benefit from a $15 min by having options. Where they probably wouldn't quit stressful jobs and risk a $6/hr pay cut, they gain leverage if quitting to flip burgers would mean $1 less. Many skilled workers making $16 would quickly be bumped up to $18-20. It wouldn't deter those who in the same breath say that unskilled workers don't deserve a living wage and that we need to boot people off welfare, but it would help real people.

Agreed. (This is a continuation of something from last week's chat, for those of you who missed it.) I haven't seen any good research showing that raising the minimum wage is harmful - again, within reason, because a $50/hour minimum wage would clearly wreak havoc.

16/02/2017 19:14
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

4f8e76f90fd2b2e03b411c307b90135e?d=identicon

JimLindeman15

Reyes out for season, not cool. I'm looking for Dakota Hudson to play a role with the big club this summer. Am I wrong?

I think you're wrong. I don't think he's ready, and I think they'll cycle through a bunch of other guys (Weaver, Rosenthal, perhaps Gonzales) first.

16/02/2017 19:15
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3ecde52d76b8ff281eb735d736f34f3b?d=identicon

Dale

Thanks for your shout out to Velocity Girl in your Top 100 songs for 2016. I miss them even though I never heard of them until yesterday.

If 'veterans' match their peaks what do you think is the potential of the A's rotation of Gray-Hahn-Manaea-Graveman-Cotton? Ho hum or one that will keep A's in most games?

I mean ... health, health, health, #5 ceiling, high-variance, in order. I guess if everything works out for all five guys that's a pretty good rotation, but what is the probability of that?

16/02/2017 19:16
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

E63aebc49cd53775b2115d06d78e7e6e?d=identicon

Gene Mullett

Of all the minor league games you see, what league do you see the most? Is there a stadium that you have visited the most? Do you have a favorite? Least favorite?

I see the Carolina League the most because it's in my backyard - I can truly go for just a few innings to see one player, or decide at the last minute to head over, because the Blue Rocks are so close. Favorite minor league stadium ever is tough - Greenville SC's is pretty wonderful. I love going to Lakewood for games where the sun sets after first pitch. Aberdeen's ballpark is amazing for short-season.

16/02/2017 19:17
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Fd144f65f19df1c7adaa116c44ce2617?d=identicon

Nick

Do you think JJ Schwarz can stick at catcher at the next level?

I think there's 0% chance of that.

16/02/2017 19:17
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

F87567f2159b425795ebb7ba9bc406ec?d=identicon

Patrick

Can Klaw do it better? Durned straight. Keith, any culinary cities in the U.S. on your current bucket list?

Portland OR. Asheville NC. I could use another few days in Austin, especially now with Vigilante Bar (a boardgame bar & restaurant) opening.

16/02/2017 19:19
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

37b8b77133ecfc1ed4740da29813ab0a?d=identicon

Pei

You put out so much work on top of your hobbies and family obligations, so clearly you use your time wisely. However, I do remember (I hope correctly!) you saying that you once were not efficient with your time and wasted a lot of it watching tv etc until you realized that you could do better, and then you did. Do you have any tips on how you were able to break your time wasting habits and develop much more fruitful ones?

The biggest problem for me was recognizing when I was wasting time - and that I could be doing "nonproductive" things (like reading, or playing games) that were more enjoyable than other time-wasters (watching mediocre TV, arguing with science deniers on Twitter)>

16/02/2017 19:20
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

8878e7050143a0fe4020498043fcc0da?d=identicon

Nate

Hey Keith, a big story last year was how Giolito changes his mechanics. Some of the articles I've seen say he decided to do it mostly on his own. But my question to you, what were these mechanical changes that were made? How did his mechanics from last year differ from previous seasons? And what do you think the White Sox will do? Will they go back to his old mechanics? If that happens, is he a top 10 prospect in the game? In other words, are the mechanical changes the lone factor that led to his drop (velocity and command being results of those changes of course) in rankings? Thanks Keith.

I haven't seen those articles, and they would be false; the Nationals' AA pitching coach did it. He already returned to his prior mechanics and I didn't drop him much at all on my rankings this winter.

16/02/2017 19:20
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

06475174d922e7dcbb3ed34c0236dbdf?d=identicon

Justin

What are your thoughts on Shed Long? Any impact potential there? Or more of a reserve type?

Reserve type. As a 2b only, he might be a tweener.

16/02/2017 19:21
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

005c8b7f8c41c3e8f4a2ac7f9ef14fe3?d=identicon

Brian In ahwatukee

I've started reading the Pulitzer list and appreciate your reviews. Do you read the nominees that don't win?

Only if they're recommended somewhere. I have Kelly Link's Get in Trouble on my to-read shelf at the moment, for example. I'll warn you some of the winners from the 1920s and 1930s are really dreadful.

16/02/2017 19:21
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

4e67af4d9f8ced24cc2feead828efbf6?d=identicon

ED

Did the debuts of Orlando Arcia, who you had 10th, and Tim Anderson, who you had 45th, change your views on them at all?

No. That would also probably be too overreactive. I did say last year that I thought promoting Anderson that soon might harm his development because he'd be hard-pressed to develop more patience while trying to just survive in the majors, but that's not about his performance.

16/02/2017 19:22
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

6a061313d22e51e0f25b7cd4dc065233?d=identicon

Max

Hi Keith, if Vlad Jr. has to move off 3B (I know you stated its a 50/50 chance he sticks) to the other side of the diamond, how much value does he lose? Is the bat good enough to profile at 1B or even DH?

Yes, he profiles as at least an above-average regular anywhere, but if he moves off 3b he'll go to RF before that worst-case scenario.

16/02/2017 19:23
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

64730ca35ed9274ff6aa8a719407fe53?d=identicon

Matthew

If you had first hand knowledge of Jays player using PEDs from your time with the org, would you be able to report that now based on any contract language you may have had? And if so, would you based on your personal reporting guidelines?

I do have this knowledge, although it's only on a couple of guys, but I would not reveal it now. It's pointless.

16/02/2017 19:23
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

2e881be8b52f84960a2873d5d8866e72?d=identicon

Kyle D

What announced but unreleased boardgame are you most looking forward to in 2017?

A Feast for Odin, La Flamme Rouge, Yamatai, First Class.

16/02/2017 19:24
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

10abad6778e8247d8fc7d68ddb02157a?d=identicon

Mike S

Moving from the city to the suburbs with my family. Any advice house shopping?

Woof, that could be its own post. School district has always reigned supreme for us when buying or selling. Also, when buying, look for anything that might be an automatic turnoff to future buyers. Our first house was a real starter home with no backyard, and that ended up a real problem when we went to sell. (And then there was one guy who literally walked out because we didn't have a fireplace. Wacko.)

16/02/2017 19:26
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Dc2054afd537ddc98afd9347136494ac?d=identicon

Tim

With the Rule Draft is 4 months away (and knowing College and HS ball will have a lot to say about the top of the draft) do Wright, Kendall, Faedo and Greene all figure in your current top 5 2017 draft prospects? At least top 10?

I posted a ranking with Chris Crawford in November: http://klaw.me/2gL6mFe I'll update that some time next month.

16/02/2017 19:26
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3f2e2531201cfbf853f16f668132eaf2?d=identicon

Philip

Which college pitcher isn't quite in the first tier like Wright and Faedo that you think could get 1-1 buzz with a realistic breakout?

Brandon McKay. In a related story, I'm seeing him tomorrow.

16/02/2017 19:26
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Ca385d14b5e4cc1536a5f1da6b18b87c?d=identicon

Ty

In last week's chat you said no to the following question "Is there a team whose 11-20 is better than another’s 1-10?". I submit Braves 11-15 of Weigel, Toussaint, Wentz, Jackson and Pache as being enough to beat AZ's list that starts off with Anthony Banda.

I'm aware of that list, and I disagree with your assessment. Banda is just outside the top 100, BTW.

16/02/2017 19:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

131b98dac8609f781484f08c22a8abaa?d=identicon

Ryan

Just how good was Nathan Kirby's stuff before the injury? I've heard some talk of three 60+ or better pitches and reasonable command. That's nuts, right?

That's not nuts, it's just inaccurate.

16/02/2017 19:27
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

69691c7bdcc3ce6d5d8a1361f22d04ac?d=identicon

M

No fault of yours, but that 'welfare' discussion last week was infuriating. When people use that word, what on earth do they think it means? It seems like every time I encounter someone complaining about 'welfare,' it is as if they are discussing some sort of guaranteed income program! Makes me think American politics would be totally different if high schools spent some time in civics class teaching students what little the social safety net actually consists of.

We do a lousy job of teaching economics in general and the politics of entitlement problems and social safety-net programs in specific. Welfare's a terrible name for what is really poverty prevention. We can disagree on specific implementations, but even ignoring the compassion angle, society is better off in the long run if its poorest children are housed, fed, and educated.

16/02/2017 19:28
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

7face1a671e869fa20fe812497afc5e8?d=identicon

@RationalMLBFan

You list/rank a wide variety of things: baseball players/teams, books, songs, board games, and food recommendations, for starters. Have you always use lists/ranking as an organizing principle? Is it a tool to help you think deeply in order to make fine distinctions between, say, #33 and #34, even though, as you normally say, there is only a minimal gap between rankings within 5 of each other on a top 100?

I'm a ranker by nature, but I've also learned that you guys love rankings. Someone asked the other day if I intended to rank 2016 movies (I do, probably Oscar Sunday). I think they just create a good starting point for any discussion because everyone will have a unique ranking.

16/02/2017 19:29
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

496f9bb98875a47ddfd6c233ea0919db?d=identicon

Rob, Gilbert AZ

What is one thing that you would eliminate from the "stadium experience" at major (or minor) league games?

No music during innings, ever. Music between innings, fine. Shut the fucking thing off when there's baseball happening.

16/02/2017 19:30
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

No music during innings, ever. Music between innings, fine. Shut the fucking thing off when there's baseball happening.

16/02/2017 19:30
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

131b98dac8609f781484f08c22a8abaa?d=identicon

Ryan

Are you watching Trump's press conference right now? This man is actually insane. How worried should this country be on a scale of 1 to 10?

I saw bits of it while I was at the gym. I think we've elected This is fine Dog as President of the United States.

16/02/2017 19:30
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

131b98dac8609f781484f08c22a8abaa?d=identicon

Ryan

How are events like the (accidental) sinking of the USS Maine, which gets used to turn fan the flames of the Spanish-American War, different than propagated fake content? or are they not? (by the way, I’d recommend recent non-fiction - The True Flag - on the idea/debate/adoption of American Imperialism at the turn of the century)

That was basically staged to start a war, no? The yellow journalism that followed it was probably the ancestor of today's fake news.

16/02/2017 19:31
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

0bb6e0a7eef8285816da2c362c27a362?d=identicon

not James Baldwin

I saw your reviews of The 13th and Loving. I was caught up in the passion of the former, forgetting to demand the data that you wanted to see in it, and haven't seen the latter. I Am Not Your Negro will be at Theatre N in Wilmington this weekend. Any plans on seeing it? If so, I'd love to read your review, unless I bump into you there.

wait, what? I've lived here three years and never been there. They're playing that and Neruda, so I might have to get to one of those. (I'd like to see both of those movies as soon as I can.)

16/02/2017 19:32
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

944facfeb153b4f01916a0f166fcc315?d=identicon

Chris

Hi Keith, I'm the one who tweeted you the pic of the SMRT office here in Portland. Just moved here up the hill from Hadlock Field. Have you ever been to a game there, supposed to be one of the better AA parks (and I'm looking forward to seeing the loaded Trenton team visit)?

Yep, great stadium, usually draw well, and obviously there will be a few prospects there too.

16/02/2017 19:33
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

9406e3c325bfc9873426e5eda4ba6e18?d=identicon

Ray

Do you think Kyle Wright/Alex Faedo are advanced enough to start 2018 in AA and see a big league cameo in 2018

No. A college player who can go right to AA is pretty rare. I think two guys did it out of the 2015 draft (Bregman and Hader).

16/02/2017 19:34
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

5e0ef665b09100b540972f6458306aba?d=identicon

Wade

I believe you've mentioned trips to Italy in the past and that you still have family there. I'm going to Croatia for our honeymoon. Ever been there? Any suggestions?

No, but Dubrovnik is a bucket-list place for me.

16/02/2017 19:34
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Bc28af6f750004729474ccbb403bd0ee?d=identicon

Scott

As grad student who can't afford a fancy coffee press or something like that, what's your best advice for making do with a regular coffee pot?

Buy a Hario V60 pour-over device - they're like $20, plus filters. Better than traditional drip or French press.

16/02/2017 19:36
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D393aaf7851d0c7d5650cccec861d9ca?d=identicon

Kilgore

How do you decide what to read next when you have a shelf full of unread books? I tend to buy A LOT of books at once and end up with so many I actually get a bit anxiety trying to decide what to read.

I almost always go in order to avoid that exact problem - or to avoid pushing a longer/more difficult book to the back of the queue. I might skip one ahead so I can alternative fiction with non-fiction, or light with heavy.

16/02/2017 19:39
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

944facfeb153b4f01916a0f166fcc315?d=identicon

Chris

Btw, if you havent been to Hadlock Field, in addition to that and seeing SMRT for yourself, Portland has an indie bookstore called Print that just opened a few months ago (signing!) and a boardgame bar that is right around the corner called Arcadia. Just sayin'.

If it wasn't inside the Arctic Circle I might move there.

16/02/2017 19:39
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

9adb41f2a66506c7e816424b455ad5ff?d=identicon

Jacob

Keith, Thanks for hosting these chats here. I realize this isn't the optimal forum for this question and you aren't a doctor, but you frequently do talk about health, so I'll ask: how many drinks a week do you think is too many? Basically if a friend or colleague said they had x drinks per week, at what point would you raise your eyebrows.

I'm definitely not qualified to answer that, but if a friend told me he was having ten drinks a week I would start to worry about him.

16/02/2017 19:40
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

Fc137b91cb8e1e13a1f7227aa5a22063?d=identicon

JR

At the gym? Trying to make sure you show up at spring training in the best shape of your life so you will fit in with everyone else?

Well I might be in the worst shape of my life right now so I need to do something about that.

16/02/2017 19:40
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

B691978b7c359668e7599688c3089eda?d=identicon

Darryl

Who loads up a bigger Brinks truck in 2 years...Machado or Harper?

If they were free agents today, Machado. But I bet Harper ends up with more in two years.

16/02/2017 19:41
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D92c25d41fcd9f8ab35545ef34b1e7ed?d=identicon

Bill

Have you have ever been surprised by someone who has retweeted one of your posts? I know the bassist from REM (a big baseball fan) does on occasion...

Yes - that's one of the best parts of Twitter. JK Rowling liked one of my tweets a few weeks ago, and when I showed my daughter she screamed "that's awesome!" and hugged me. (She's 10. And a huge Potter fan.) Didn't know that about Mills, though.

16/02/2017 19:43
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

3e06fa3927cbdf4e9d93ba4541acce86?d=identicon

Michael

How do you feel about immigrants closing their restaurants? We are all immigrants except the Native Americans. Keep the restaurant open and market that there are great cuisines and cultures to be enjoyed through food. Don't know how closing and losing profits helps- any insights?

It makes news. I think that's the point. And I agree, we're all immigrants. My ancestors came from Italy (one grandparent, four other great-grandparents), Ireland (one great-great grandparent), and England (not sure how far back, but that's where Law comes from).

16/02/2017 19:44
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

2c3baf26f776086aab9f234f8c9a00ed?d=identicon

Felix

If your the Reyes TJ news had come out before you finished your rankings how far down the list do you think it would drop him?

Good question. I usually dock guys who are just out with TJ pretty substantially - probably to around the 30-40 range, maybe a touch lower because I feel like the delivery offered us clues that he'd get hurt. This is why Reyes 1) wasn't my top pitching prospect and 2) couldn't possibly be over guys like Benintendi or Swanson. Hell, I'll bet there isn't a GM in baseball right now who would have traded Benintendi for a fully healthy Reyes a week ago.

16/02/2017 19:46
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

2fc1c0beb992cd7096975cfebf9d5c3b?d=identicon

Bob

With Alex Reyes out for the year, it appears that Wacha is going to get the first crack at being the fifth starter for STL. If I recall right, you were never as high on him as others were and his performance has been uneven at best. If he has indeed strengthened the muscles around his shoulder, what would you expect from him going forward?

My concern with him was really around the lack of an average breaking ball. He had an average fastball, 70 changeup, and above-average or plus command. Never thought he'd be inconsistent or regularly injured, so I take no credit here. If I'm Mozeliak, I'm putting Wacha in the mix for that spot, but figuring I get 15 starts from him, 10 from someone else, etc. I wouldn't bank on him going 180 innings.

16/02/2017 19:47
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

B9f70cbb473c65c19063cc40e14be4c4?d=identicon

Howard

I have an Anova sous vide and I'm looking for some good, cheap options to sous vide - in particular, chicken? Any specific chicken recipes you've tried on that that came out amazing?

Yes, Serious Eats has a chicken thighs (or legs) recipe that is foolproof. I also use the tip from Richard Blais' Try This at Home to sous vide boneless breasts for about an hour at 145-150 - I've even done 155 and they're still good but 150 is probably ideal - to use later in applications like chicken salad. I've done that to shred chicken for soups too. It comes out way more tender.

16/02/2017 19:48
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

633d6abff0a3fc22404347728d195059?d=identicon

RAW

How do you get over the feeling that brain power devoted now to baseball (also, all sports & entertainment) is not wasteful, fake news?

I think about it for a moment and then I go on living my life.

16/02/2017 19:48
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

083d9a270e6e16b2fbb08d35067aae5f?d=identicon

Dave

Does Braden Shipley still have a future as a starter? He's dropped off the prospect list map.

He dropped off because he lost his eligibility. Yes, I absolutely believe he's a starter. Too athletic and too good a changeup & curveball.

16/02/2017 19:49
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

4fe7a911471f5b55faa31471ffde55ce?d=identicon

Robert Gsellman

What makes Robert Gsellman so different than Michael Fulmer?

Fulmer had better secondary stuff at the same stage of development.

16/02/2017 19:49
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw

D52e32f3a96a64786814ae9b5279fbe5?d=identicon

James

What do you think of Josh Ockimey? He was so good in his first 75-80 games and so bad in his final 40 or so. I would imagine he's an extreme risk, but it he a risky guy you like?

Yep, he's in my Boston org writeup, and it was just what you said. Has to hit, since he's 1b only, but he really seemed to hit a wall in late July and was just toast.

16/02/2017 19:50
Missing avatar thumb

Klaw