Klawchat 3/4/16
If they're out of hand, I'm a give 'em handles. Klawchat.
Tim
What's your opinion of Andy Green?
I really know nothing of him as a tactical manager, but I like that the Padres actually considered managerial experience in the minors as if it has value (it absolutely does, in my opinion), and I have heard great things about his work with young players. I'm cautiously optimistic.
Klaw
Stevie
Does Tom Murphy start at C for Col in '16?
If healthy? Might be a bit of a leap now, but possible later in the season.
Klaw
Brian
The Braves seem to have a decent number of minor leaguers that should be able to hit, but there aren't many with big power projection. Do you view this as a problem?
I don't know that I think that's true - Davidson certainly projects for power - and power is a relatively scarce commodity. But I think this qualifies as looking for something to worry about: they have lots of pitching and players up the middle, so if they do have to trade for a power bat at a corner at some point they should have the pieces to do so.
Klaw
Daniel
Back on the old ESPN chat days, you characterized and had concerns about Manaea being "all deception" in regards to his stuff and potential output. Have things changed given your current ranking of him?
I don't think that's an accurate summary of my views on him at any point. It's not like he was throwing 85 and getting guys out. He wasn't throwing 96 like he did on the Cape, but I've seen him multiple times as a pro and he's generally been at least 88-93, more often 90-94, with an above-average slider. Deception is why he puts up huge K rates despite stuff that's more grade 55-60 than grade 65-70.
Klaw
chris
what games did you go to yesterday
I saw Nolan Martinez, Chris Murphy, and Nick Lodolo. I'm going to see Mickey Moniak today and probably Reggie Lawson tomorrow. The weather is screwing up my trip - I would have had the chance to see Lawson and Kevin Gowdy, but their games are now at the same time.
Klaw
Jacob
Do you think the Braves should be encouraged by the standout performances (and surprising power)of Mallex Smith and Ozhaino Albies and does it bode well for their seasons?
No, I think spring training stats are totally meaningless and trying to draw any conclusions from three days of games would only qualify you to participate in last night's GOP debate.
Klaw
John Uskglass
How confident are you in J. Profar still being an above average player?
One hundred percent. If he's healthy, he'll be above average.
Klaw
Andrew
What are your thoughts on Chris Lee's progression since coming over to the O's system from Houston? Could Baltimore actually be successfully developing talent for once?
You'll have to be more specific; I saw Lee's last start of 2015 and saw more or less what he's been before.
Klaw
Matt
Is Ahmed Rosario more than just a glove?
Yes. Someone asked Jonathan Mayo that same question on Twitter and I was dumbfounded. That's a bad fake-scouting report going around if people think that's what he is.
Klaw
Philip
Padres supposedly have secret deals with Jorge Ona and Adrian Morejon I know you answered a question few weeks ago on Morejon and seem high on him. What about Ona?
I've heard better on Morejon, but still good things on Ona. Still haven't seen either. Once they're locked up in deals, they turn into phantasms.
Klaw
BD
Mike Shawaryn a worthy late first rounder?
Will see him in April but area guys were telling me more like second round coming into the spring.
Klaw
Mike P.
Who will be more known at the end of the season in Milwaukee: Hank or Arcia?
I have no idea how this Hank story became a thing. Maybe Michigan's Gov. Snyder should concoct a fake-dog story because it certainly seemed to generate more reader interest than poisoning kids in Flint has.
Klaw
G
Do you listen to much Hip Hop? Any opinion on Kanye's "The Life of Pablo" or Kendrick's new release?
Oh, I like hip hop, but please don't lump Kanye into that genre. I thought untitled unmastered was much more interesting and streamlined than TPAB, and while he could have used some editing (track 7 anyone?), there are some real highlights that brought me back to the brief peak of jazz-rap, particularly track 8 and track 3.
Klaw
Cole
Where does Alex Bregman fit with the Astros? Wouldn't think he is the guy defensively to make Correa move to third and Jose Altuve i still at second. Is his arm strong enough for third base? Is a move to the outfield inevitable?
It's a 50 arm if you like it, 45 if you don't. Second base is his ideal position. I wonder if the Astros figured he was the best player available at 2 in their minds, so if there isn't an opportunity (with Altuve signed through 2019 including options, there probably isn't one), Bregman would be the centerpiece in any trade for a big leaguer in July.
Klaw
Andrew
You've mentioned the Rockies shortened Gray's delivery. I seem to remember something similar being said about their handling of Matzek coming up. Is this a common practice in their development process and potentially problematic a la the Orioles?
They really altered Matzek's delivery, but aside from those two guys i'm not sure what other examples we have there. Often it's these kids going to coaches in their offseasons, like Taijuan Walker and Aaron Sanchez apparently did, rather than getting it from coaches.
Klaw
Zach
Promise it's not driven by a hot spring start. How good is Mazara's hit tool?
Now, probably a 40 or 45. Future, jeez, if you wanted to push me to say 60 I wouldn't argue too hard. He's always had an approach well beyond his age.
Klaw
Jonny B
I always get overexcited about spring training performances, despite understanding that it is foolish to do so. However, I am curious if you think there is anything about spring training that might be predictive or informative (particularly relating to prospects)?
If a kid shows up looking different physically or mechanically, that might mean something significant. I heard secondhand that David Rollins was throwing harder with a better slider than before - now that's a guy I would want to watch. But you can take the spring training stats sheet into the bathroom with you in case the stall is out of toilet paper.
Klaw
Craig
You mentioned that you find minor league experience very useful for evaluating possible MLB managers? Because a minor league manager's job is primarily about developing talent (a team would be thrilled with a manager who routinely finished last in his league, but consistently developed players), what traits/experiences from the minors are useful? I'm genuinely curious.
I disagree that that's all there is to a minor league manager's job. No team would be thrilled with a manager who routinely finished last, because the affiliate (if it's not owned by the MLB team) would be seriously pissed off and would seek a new affiliation - and no MLB team wants to end up in High Desert. The actual experience of running a club, handling tactical situations in-game, and balancing developmental needs with trying to win is valuable and can't be replicated through any means other than experience.
Klaw
Thomas I. Shollar
Yo Bro, trying to up my home brew game....not a home espresso drinker more of a pour over homie...Baratza Encore get it done for a grinder or is that still JV?
I think it would. I own their Virtuoso but it's because I needed a consistent, finer grind for espresso.
Klaw
Jay
Your comment on Mac Wiliamson's bat speed being a tad slow...is that based on what you saw pre or post surgery?
Post. Saw him in AFL.
Klaw
Bartolo4ever
I read your review of Spotlight. Just out of curiosity, which was the scene that "rang a little false" for you?
Ruffalo's character blowing up at Keaton. Not sure if it actually happened or not, but it seemed very made-for-commercial.
Klaw
Andrew
Re: Chris Lee--> when in Houston never made it past A ball, fb sat at 89 and command shaky. Since coming to baltimore got to AA, fb 93-96, stronger and seems to have better command this spring
He's not 93-96 as a starter. Might do that in relief - I heard he did in instructs in short stints - but that's not really a change when you take a guy from starting to relief and see his velocity increase.
Klaw
Greg T.
Is Daulton Jefferies a first rounder?
Yes. Although I'm not totally sure he's there on merit.
Klaw
Ed
If you're the cubs, do you approach this draft differently? Like, would you utilize your available scouting resources to spend more time scouting the lower ranked or diamond in the rough types? Or do you approach it same as always?
Well they have so little money to spend relative to other teams that I'd probably avoid many of the HS kids who are expected to go first round and wouldn't be signable for less than first-round money. Can still find value later in the draft; perhaps there's a way to scout those guys more efficiently when you're not spending resources scouting Corey Ray or Jason Groome.
Klaw
Dusty
Do you see any scenario where Desmond plays SS for the Rangers?
If Andrus gets hurt or hits even worse than he did in 2015, don't they have to try it?
Klaw
Jake
Any industry rumors around who the Phillies will take at number 1?
No. And if there were, they'd be bogus. It's three months from the draft and there's no Bryce Harper type to make this an easy question.
Klaw
Kyle
I always admire your stances on twitter and speaking up on things like Baylor and Tennessee. In light of that, I'm curious to hear your thoughts on the Erin Andrews news and how you feel to be working for the same company that would make her live through that on TV
I was not happy to see that at all, and I won't say a word to defend ESPN's actions, but I also have no idea who those executives might have been or if they're still with the company. I can only hope that if they are still around that they are being made to answer for their actions. Erin deserved so much better.
Klaw
Andrew
Pick one: Pandemic or Catan
Pandemic.
Klaw
Chris P
Are you looking to make any spring games, or is it all HS/college at this point?
I have gone to spring training every year since joining ESPN. This year is no different.
Klaw
Mike
If once of the Cardinals current starting five went down tomorrow, would you put Reyes on the 40 Man?
I would have done it anyway just to make it clear that I think suspensions for weed are stupid. I have real optimism that the union is going to try to get that eliminated in the next CBA. I'm in California now and I could probably be legally high right now (I'm not, just to make that clear). There's no justification for MLB being this far behind the times.
Klaw
Anonymous
Keith,
Do you think the Pirates treatment of Gerrit Cole is an example of an exploited inefficiency on PIT's part? Figure a pitcher isn't likely to be healthy or affordable by the time he is a FA, the player will take advantage of arbitration, why give a raise now?
I wouldn't have tried or threatened to cut him, but as I said on the BBTN podcast, there is no benefit to paying these guys more before they're arb-eligible. I just wouldn't go out of my way to antagonize them.
Klaw
wrburgess
Who would you bet on being the 2016 version of Conforto, such as a 2015 draft pick that, given the chance, makes a late-season impact in the majors?
I think Benintendi could do that. Hell, Bregman could do it if Altuve or Correa had some serious injury.
Klaw
Nik
Which team will make the playoffs first, the Phillies or the Braves?
Hm. I think Atlanta is more motivated to go spend some money to improve the team quickly in 2017-18, but the Phillies' prospects are a bit closer to helping the big-league club.
Klaw
Michael
Do you call out your colleagues when they refer to RBIs, OPS, "clutch," or other stats/concepts you disagree with, like you do with people on Twitter? Is that uncomfortable?
I have done so on Twitter and on air. I've called out colleagues for supporting anti-science and pseudoscience too. So this seems like a very silly question.
Klaw
Amit
Check out any eats while you were in the bay?
Cotogna, del Popolo, flour + water, Four Barrel, Sightglass.
Klaw
Clay
Have you ever tried curing your own meat? Would love to try but I worry about getting it wrong and making people sick.
I've cured and smoked bacon. I haven't done anything to be eaten uncooked like prosciutto.
Klaw
Ryan
Out of all of the Braves pitching prospects who's most likely to reach/come close to expectations?
Aaron Blair, because he's just about there already.
Klaw
Scott
With Archie Bradley and Jon Gray both reportedly showing increased velocity on their first spring turns, seems like both of their local media are hoping for the best and forgetting it was two inning stints after a long stretch off. How much of their problems the last two years can be tied directly to the lost ticks on their fastball?
A lot. Although Bradley also had issues with his shoulder, and both guys have struggled to develop a good third pitch.
Klaw
Ciscoskid
Any prospects that are top 2 rounds worthy out of Northern CA?
Jefferies and Matt Manning are the two definites, although Manning is playing hoops and won't make his first start until April 11th.
Klaw
Colin
what disgusted you most about the GOP debate last night?
I actually didn't watch it; I've only read recaps and reactions, which of course are going to highlight the most ridiculous moments.
Klaw
William
re: Spotlight....that Ruffalo weird accent/cadence he was going for didn't annoy the living hell out of you?
No - actually, I thought it enhanced the performance because it made him fall into character more. Plus I don't know what Rezendes actually sounds like; I read an interview with Sascha Pfeifer which one of you sent to me where she said the actors all worked to adopt the real reporters' accents and gestures.
Klaw
Kevin
Thoughts on fantasy baseball (not daily). Good for the game or a hindrance?
Good for the game. Daily fantasy, not so much.
Klaw
Kevin
Best rapper ever?
Rakim. I'll entertain an argument for 2Pac, but Rakim is known by a single letter for a reason.
Klaw
H ramirez end the season as the Sox 1B?
Yes. I think he's going to hit better than expected. He was OK before he slammed into the wall last year.
Klaw
Michael
You made it seem like it was completely wrong to be in the minority on the gay marriage cases last week on Twitter. While you may not agree with originalism, it's a legitimate way to interpret the Constitution. The ratifiers of the 14th Amendment never thought they were giving people the right to marry a person of the same sex. Leave it to the legislature.
There are two problems with this. The ratifiers of the 14th amendment promised due process under the law to all, with no exceptions or conditions. Indeed, the authors or ratifiers of the Constitution or any amendment could not have imagined the world in which we live today, and saying that if they didn't anticipate modern technology, biology, knowledge of genetics (of which they had none), and so on that the documents don't apply renders them useless. As for Scalia's argument that marriage equality should have been left to state legislatures, that's an outright failure because so many federal laws and policies - including the favorable tax treatment of married couples and survivors' benefits in social security - rely on marital status that it is undeniably a federal issues. Scalia was smart enough to know this, but let his own opposition to gay marriage inform his opinion instead.
Klaw
Dan
Periscopes coming back soon?
Tough to do those when I'm on a plane or in a car all the time.
Klaw
Chris
Agree with the 30 games for Aroldis? I thought it was light, to be honest.
I thought it was reasonable for a negotiated settlement (no appeal) in a case where the victim recanted, so whatever additional evidence MLB may have gathered that we don't have, their case against Chapman was likely weaker than they'd wanted.
Klaw
Steve
What kind of line would you expect from Park in Minnesota this year?
.250ish with 75 walks and 20-25 homers? I don't know him that well as a player, just some video.
Klaw
Michael
I meant, do you do it in person? Doing it behind the comfort of a computer screen is a lot easier.
Really? I would never say anything online or in a text that I wouldn't repeat in person. You seem ignorant of what my job actually entails. When I say the Angels have the worst farm system I've ever seen, I still talk to many people in their organization and must be willing to stand up and answer for what I've said.
Klaw
Fitzy
Does the White Sox initial aggressive assignment of Courtney Hawkins explain why he's never really developed?
It's a strong hypothesis, and in my opinion, a good one that's probably incomplete. He was fairly crude to begin with and there was always a chance he'd never hit.
Klaw